The Sumter Post 15 website is currently down for rentals and programs. Anyone who wishes to reach American Legion Post 15 regarding the charter revocation, upcoming fair, P-15s baseball or venue rentals may email helppost15@gmail.com.
UPDATE AS OF 12:40 p.m., Saturday, Aug. 16: American Legion Post 15 will continue with venue rentals and the farmers market as of Saturday afternoon, according to the Post's website. Programs like P-15's summertime baseball and Boy and Girl Scouts are thought to be suspended until further notice.
The 106-year-old Sumter County Fair is in jeopardy after the American Legion Department of South Carolina revoked the charter of Post 15 on Thursday night, immediately suspending all programs and freezing local operations.
The action halts the post’s ability to conduct business – including the fair, scheduled for Sept. 9-14 – unless state and local leaders intervene.
The decision comes after months of internal turmoil at Post 15, where disputes over elections, control of bank accounts and adherence to Legion bylaws has caused a divide among Post leadership and stalled preparations for the annual six-day family friendly event. The fair committee, led by Shawn and Nicole Custer, continued planning despite being locked out of facilities and finances, but with the charter revocation, final authority lies in the hands of the State Legion and could determine whether the event will ever happen again.
SUSPICIOUS ACTIVITY
The Custers, both veterans, joined Post 15 nearly five years ago to get involved in initiatives and programs that benefit local youth, namely the P-15 summertime baseball league – Shawn once announced the games – and the American Legion Post 15 Fair.
Also known as Sumter County Fair or Sumter American Legion Fair, the event features rides, games, food, art and animal exhibits. It has been organized and run by American Legion Post 15 since 1919, with gate sales helping support their community outreach efforts, like the Boy and Girl Scouts and the P-15 junior and senior baseball program, which expanded in 2021 to have as many as three softball teams but one active team currently. Annually, the event can attract 20,000-plus people.
After the passing of two long-time fair committee members, Nicole Custer was named fair chairman in 2023 and Shawn Custer fair manager in 2024, maintaining the fairground on West Liberty Street and managing accounts and documents concerning the event’s operations. It’s in that capacity Nicole first noticed activity she found suspicious within the Post 15 bank accounts.
Six months into her position, deposits for rental fees for the Post’s two buildings on South Artillery Drive – the Post’s home building and Fair Memorial Building – were bringing in around the same amount of money. This raised red flags as the Memorial Building is rented for nearly $400 less than the other.
“Why would this nicer building be making just barely more than the other one?” Shawn told The Item.
The matter would raise questions well into June, when Nicole and fair committee treasurer Pamela Sterner went into work to continue planning for the fair — only to be served a trespass notice by Quint Klopfleisch, the alleged former Post adjutant and member of the Post’s executive committee.
Shawn Custer and another fair committee member were also served a trespass notice — a “generic” letter that cited “financial improprieties” and “unbecoming” conduct of a legionnaire, Custer said. He said they refused to leave because there is a process to impose a punishment of that kind on a member in good standing.
An affidavit that includes the charges must go before the full executive committee. Then, an impartial investigation is conducted by the Post’s investigation committee which then delivers a report to the executive committee to vote on whether the issue should go to Legion trial. If it does, the trial allows both sides to present evidence before a Post jury decides their fate. Only then is a punishment decided.
None of this happened, Custer said.
Instead, he alleges Quint and his wife, Cleo Klopfleisch; Dorian Brunson; and Bill Lyons — all of whom were a part of the Post’s 15-member executive committee — removed him and the others from their fair roles to take away their power to vote or participate in the Post’s annual election by having them under investigation.
“The bylaws are very clear that the Post’s [full] executive committee is in charge, not any of the individual officers,” said Liz Guthridge, a registered professional parliamentarian with the National Association of Parliamentarians who has worked with the Custers. “The officers in this case avoided taking action required under their governing documents, the constitution and bylaws. Their lack of action and compliance takes inefficiency to a new unacceptable level.”
ACCORDING TO THE BYLAWS
According to the constitution of Sumter Post 15, “all officers shall be elected annually, and they shall hold office until their successors are duly installed or as otherwise provided.”
Nominations are submitted in April with the election happening the first Monday in May and new officers being installed at the regular meeting in June — the way it has been for 100 years, according to the Post 15 constitution. This year, however, was different.
According to Shawn Custer, the four executive committee members reasoned that the full group did not give Post members a two-week notice of the election, so, therefore, it should be postponed to June. He refuted, stating Legion elections are a known occurrence each year; no notice is needed.
Custer had planned to run for Post commander. He said he thinks the four members feared they could lose their positions and, ultimately, their influence if he were elected.
Post members were not informed of why the Custers and others were trespassed, just that they were being investigated by Sumter Police Department.
A case report obtained by The Item detailed Cleo Klopfleisch filed a breach of trust with fraudulent intent valued at $10,000 or more against Nicole Custer in May for an alleged incident first noticed in March 2024. She was “exceptionally cleared” on June 30, according to the report.
The Custers told the other 11 executive committee members what was happening, which angered them.
Meanwhile, Shawn Custer alleged Cleo Klopfleisch took control of all bank accounts, passwords, websites logins and billing for the Post and the fair. The Custers and others on the fair committee were “stonewalled” out of planning, he said.
Since they were trespassed from the property, the members held a special-called meeting in the banquet hall of a local restaurant on July 29 with an attendance of 33 legionnaires; the four executive members did not attend as they were “busy,” according to Custer. The purpose of the meeting was to narrow down the needs for the 2025 fair and discuss the conduct and actions of Lyons, Brunson, the Klopfleisches and a fifth executive member, Jack McCall.
A letter from State Department of the American Legion read aloud during the meeting stated the department was “not concerned with elections” and “does not run local Post.” This would come after the Custers and the Klopfleischs each presented their side of the dispute to the state department. Custer said he hoped that by informing them of the issues at hand, the department would step in to restore order or, at least, assist in doing so.
Post members took that to mean it was up to them to regain control. In a unanimous vote, Shawn and Nicole Custer were reinstated, giving them back their membership privileges and status and removing the trespass warning.
The board also moved to hold the election on Aug. 4, three months after it was supposed to take place, to give the fair committee immediate access to the building historically belonging to the fair and its keys and to remove the Klopfleisches, Brunson, McCall and Lyons from accessing all passwords, logins, keys, billings and bank accounts pertaining to fair operations. The votes were unanimous.
Claims of unauthorized payments, improper paying of invoices, attempts to withhold employee pay and “other costly actions beyond her held title as historian” were made against Cleo Klopfleisch. At the time of publishing, Post 15 remains under the state department’s Confidential Investigation Committee. The Item reached out for clarification on these allegations and the state’s control but did not receive a response by press time. Klopfleisch forwarded The Item’s questions to the state.
In a letter dated Aug. 4 and received by members Aug. 5, the department stated Post 15 could continue to conduct the 2025 fair, with keys being returned to Brunson at its conclusion. The department also said “there will be no elections held until further notice.”
The Post’s constitution also states that any officer or executive committeeman may be removed for “inefficiency” by the Post’s full executive committee with a two-thirds vote, Guthridge, the parliamentarian, told The Item.
Though the votes were unanimous, the five members are believed to still be operating in their positions: Brunson as acting commander, McCall as acting first vice commander, Quint Klopfleisch as post adjutant, Cleo Klopfleisch as historian/webmaster and Lyons as acting baseball director.
“Which makes them noncompliant with the wishes and actions of the executive committee,” Guthridge said. “This is odd behavior.”
THE ELECTION
Following the special-called meeting, the Klopfleischs, Brunson, Lyons and McCall were notified of their removal from their duties, but not their membership, and to turn over the keys to the Post buildings, including the building historically designated for fair operations. The notice was ignored, Shawn Custer said. A locksmith was called to change the door locks, restoring control to the fair committee.
Elections were held at the regularly scheduled meeting on Aug. 4. Despite an alleged attempt by Quint Klopfleisch, according to Custer, to cancel the meeting, 55 members attended, more than the 30 members who regularly attend. Unanimous votes removed Brunson, McCall and the Klopfleisches from their executive duties and elected new officers, including Shawn Custer as post adjutant and rides director for the fair, and reinstated Nicole Custer as fair chairman and Sterner as treasurer.
Yet, the issue of access to funds was still on the table.
According to Shawn Custer, an attempt to regain access to the bank accounts was blocked when the bank teller was told they were “bank thieves” and “robbers.” He said he fears that without access to the Post’s money, “not only is it [the fair] not going to happen, but chances are that it will never happen again.”
This would be the 106th year the American Legion Post 15 Fair runs in Sumter County. The only time its grand Ferris wheel didn’t glow was during the COVID-19 pandemic and Hurricane Hugo.
But Custer hasn’t lost hope.
FAIR FUTURE IN LIMBO
In a phone call with The Item the morning of Friday, Aug. 15, he detailed the State Department of the American Legion’s appearance at its meeting on Thursday Aug. 14. The state revoked the Post’s charter, immediately suspending all programs – that includes the fair, P-15s baseball league, Boy and Girl Scouts clubs and Post venue rentals (only of the fairgrounds and Post buildings; the civic center is city-owned and not impacted).
“They're not saying a single word as to what the complaint is,” he told The Item.
In a letter dated Aug. 14 and published to the American Legion Post 15 website, the state department launched an investigation into Post 15 on July 9 after receiving "numerous complaints." Based on their findings and recommendations, a special-called meeting was held Wednesday, Aug. 13 where the state executive committee unanimously voted to revoke the Post's charter, "effective immediately."
Prior to the meeting, Shawn Custer had opened a second bank account to collect funds for the fair, which costs an estimated $80,000 to host. Some donations have been made already, though a specific amount was not disclosed. The meeting on Aug. 14 was to discuss how to collect more money.
The Item obtained video footage of legionnaires at the meeting being told by State Commander James Rabon to leave the building or face arrest. As legionnaires shouted, “Why can’t we know what’s going on?” Rabon said he would not make any statements, take any statements or allow any questions. The Boy Scouts meeting in the memorial building was also told to stop and attendees to leave, Shawn Custer told The Item.
“This Post is now the property of the American Legion Department of South Carolina,” Rabon said.
Nearly 25 days out from the fair’s opening day, Custer is holding out hope to keep the annual attraction going. But he said he knows it’ll take help from local and state leadership.
“The only thing that I have hoped for is that the attorney general could come and put an injunction on it … to not let this happen and put the brakes on everything so that the city won't have to go without a fair,” he told The Item. “[We have] people's weddings that are planned all through the rest of this year. We have so many things going on that are going to destroy people's lives.”
He told The Item there is a wedding scheduled for this weekend that may not happen.
He said he has spoken with several longtime vendors and contracted acts about the fair’s status. If the event doesn't happen, the Post could be sued for breaching contracts.
“All these people [in the industry], they all talk and they all work together. If you get blackballed, you’re done,” he said.
The same goes for rental agreements with the two venues.
More Articles to Read
